Mother and Infant talk about mental states: systemic emergence of psychological lexicon and theory of mind understanding

In recent years, a number of studies that have examined how social experiences are related to children’s theory of mind development, have found that: (1) the frequency of mothers’ mental state utterances used in mother-child picture-book reading, is correlated with children’s theory of mind abilities; (2) mothers’ use of cognitive terms is related more strongly to children’s theory of mind performances than the mothers’ references to other mental states, such as desires or emotions (Adrian, Clemente, Villanueva, Rieffe, 2005; Ruffman, Slade, Crowe, 2002; Taumoepeau, Ruffman, 2006; Dunn, 2002). Despite the evidence for the role of mothers’ language, there is disagreement over how exactly it improves children’s theory of mind development. In short, mentalistic comments contain distinctive words, grammatical constructions and pragmatic features. The question is, however, which factor is critical (de Rosnay, Pons, Harris, Morrell, 2004). The present study addresses this issue and focuses on relationship between mothers’ mental state terms and children’s performances in theory of mind tasks (emotion understanding and false belief tasks). Mothers were asked to read some pictures to 10 children between 3;0 and 5;0. Among the different mental state references (perceptual, emotional, volitional, cognitive, moral and communicative), it was found that the frequency and variety of mothers’ mental state words were significantly associated with children’s mental lexicon. In addition, emotional terms correlated positively with children’s false belief performance. Kind of emotional words that are used by the mothers with reference to the Italian language will be discussed.